Feature Creep: Where the PlayStation 4 is Lacking

Feature Creep: Where the PlayStation 4 Is Lacking

While the upcoming PlayStation 4 has been revealed with a mixed but overall positive reception, questions nevertheless remain. Some advertised features seem promising if inconcrete. However, what Electronic Arts has begun truly sounds like the promise of a new generation in gaming.

Recently, Sony showed off its vision of the PlayStation 4. The new controller, the social and sharing functions, the cloud based capabilities, the PC architecture, the 6X Blu-ray drive and the first slate of games all impress, but something is missing. That something isn’t as mundane as the price point, the release date or even a mock-up of the actual console. It isn’t exactly the dissipating promise for PS3 (not to mention PS2 and PS1) software. The PS4, with its conservative and traditional attempt to take a generational leap, is missing something that another big company has finally begun to execute.

This company was noticeably absent from the PS4 reveal, and yet undoubtedly will be a big part of the platform. The feature that Sony has not thought to offer, but that I can’t help but wish for, is breaking ground at Electronic Arts, of all places.

In broad strokes, Electronic Arts’ “Single Identity” represents the company’s desire to tie various platforms together. Ever ready to publish on multiple platforms, EA now sees an advantage in linking its titles together across the PC, Mac, PS3, 360 and iOS. Whether we’re talking about ‘Madden’, ‘Mass Effect’ or ‘Need for Speed’, EA wants the player to have a single identity that ties their achievements, their friends, their title ownership and their save file across platforms.

Where the PS4 teases Remote Play through the Vita, or backwards compatibility through Gakai, EA looks to provide greater gaming freedom. Just imagine if the consumer knew for certain that purchasing a game meant getting its best current version. On the developer side, knowing that (no matter what) each consumer would buy either directly or indirectly the best version of a title would hopefully mean that consumers are never truly locked out from content. As in, if a consumer buys the version for platform A, then he also gets it for B, C, D and E. If platform C is the best version, the one that was used primarily for development, each buyer of the game would own that version and could always decide to play it. This would allow the platform (i.e. the format) to be nothing more than a preference.

Now, if we further that example and release a new platform like the PS4, EA can offer to add the new version to the gamer’s Single Identity. The consumer could buy in, knowing that not only would his game saves, achievements, friends, etc. migrate seamlessly, but that he still owned the old version too. When applied to downloadable content, selling it at a per-title rather than platform specific level would be very enticing for consumers, even if they never took advantage of different versions of the game. Ensuring perceived value in the digital ownership age is vitally important.

And that’s just it. At a time when buying a movie can mean getting a Blu-ray, Digital Copy and DVD, but still knowing that the 3D or Ultra HD version will be out sooner or later (not to mention Netflix streaming), the PS4, like everything else prevalent in the entertainment industry at the moment, pushes the idea of having a collection of games, movies, etc. further away. EA’s Single Identity concept brings into play a practical consideration, retaining use of a game beyond the amount shelf space it occupies.

[Current information about Single Identity comes from Venture Beat.]


  1. JM

    Sony should remaster PS3 hits to 1080p/60fps/Ultra quality for the PS4, as free downloads for PS+, available at launch.

    EA sounds useful for a lot of people who are not me.

    I bought a 360 at launch, but I see no reason to get the next Xbox. I’ll bet 1.8 teraflops that the best versions this generation will be on PS4.

    “Save anywhere/instant resume” is my vote for the game changer, especially if I can switch between PS4 and Vita.

    But what I most want is an RPG that lets me customize every character model, object, environment, and animation as part of new game+…

  2. Why would the best versions be on the PS4, there has been nothing said about what the next Xbox is going to officially bring and I highly doubt that it will make a difference since both consoles are going X86 with hardware pretty much, AMD based CPU and Graphics in the PS4 and I cant imagine that the next Xbox is going to be much different as the 360 was the closest to a PC out of anyone this generation.

    I’m getting the next Xbox for sure, I’m a Halo fan and Halo 5 is all the reason I need, plus I love Xbox Live over PSN (even though PSN+ is very nice) so I’m not even caring much about the PS4 this generation, same goes with Nintendo, havent even wanted to play with the WiiU at all.

    • JM

      PS4 gets Sony’s 4K movie download service, 100GB files.

      + Bethesda & Bioware & Japan on the Vita.

      We’ll have to see how much Microsoft invested in Kinect vs GPU…

      Since I don’t do multiplayer, my attachment to ‘Halo 5/6’ is Cortana dependent.

      But I would totally buy an Xbox if they reimagined ‘BC’ as a ‘Far Cry 3’-killer.

  3. Sidestepping those Xbox vs. PlayStation vs. Nintendo battle lines,I obviously think that EA should pursue this Single Identity to a point where Origin offers something more useful than Steam delivers, but already you see Microsoft bringing XBLA exclusive titles to the Windows 8 store, and Sony trying to get PS Mobile some traction. If companies want to hold all your content behind a login and track everything that you play and do, the least that they can do is make that content as accessible as possible.

    • That would be really nice as its a pain when you cant cross platform anything. Take Zen Pinball 2 for the 360 or Windows 8, I can log into my Xbox Live account through the game in Windows 8 and I own most of the tables on the 360 version, but I cant bring any of those over, I have to re-purchase the ones I already own if I want to play them on the PC. I get buying them separately for Android as its not their OS, but not being able to get the same tables I already bought on Microsofts own console AND OS is stupid

      Oh and the Vita is a complete waste of time and I could also care less about whats happening in Japan with anything 🙂 So again, no reason why the PS4 would/should/could be better IMO

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *