‘The Cape’ Pilot Recap: One Bad Fashion Statement

Honestly, did anyone expect NBC’s new superhero series ‘The Cape’ to be good? No, we didn’t. Everything about it looks atrocious. Now it’s aired and, no surprise, it is atrocious!

Ever since ‘Heroes finally bottomed out and had to be dragged off the air, NBC has been desperate to reclaim the nerd audience that made that show a hit in its first season or so. The network’s stab at sci-fi with ‘The Event‘ hasn’t seemed to do the trick, so now we’re right back to comic book territory.

‘The Cape’ isn’t based on a real comic (at least, not that I know of), but is rather a generic mishmash of dozens that you’ve probably read, or are at least passably familiar with. Whereas ‘Heroes’ was sort of a new millennial ‘X-Men’ or ‘The Avengers’-style team comic title, ‘The Cape’ is a very old fashioned (I’m sure the producers would prefer the word “classic”) costumed crimefighter tale reminiscent of early ‘Batman’ or ‘The Shadow’.

The 2-hour premiere is actually two separate episodes (‘Pilot’ and ‘Tarot’) run back-to-back. Although the credits in between were stripped out, the two halves have little continuity. The first part is bog-standard superhero origin story stuff. We’ve got a do-gooder loner named Vince Faraday (David Lyons from ‘ER’) living in a corrupt town (the fictional Palm City) who is egregiously wronged and so decides to put on a costume to fight crime and protect the innocent. Faraday was an upright cop who made the mistake of digging too deeply into the dealings of the shady ARK Corporation and its evil CEO Peter Fleming (James Frain from this past season of ‘True Blood’), who doubles as the city’s nefarious supervillain named Chess.

When Faraday gets too close, Fleming frames him for being Chess and murdering the city’s police chief, then arranges to have him killed. Faraday barely escapes an explosion that leaves everyone else (including his wife and precocious son) believing that he’s dead. But he’s rescued by a kooky circus troupe called the Carnival of Crime, whose ringmaster Max Malini (Keith David, whose hammy performance is by far the most entertaining aspect of the show) decides to play Yoda. Max gives Vince a special cape made out of rare spider silk or some nonsense that’s as strong as steel and as flexible as a rubber band. The troupe also teaches Vince how to fight, how to hypnotize people, and how to pull off a disappearing act – all things that will come in handy when knocking heads with the city’s criminal underworld. Once he puts together a costume including the cape and a hood… Voila, instant superhero!

After establishing his new identity, The Cape makes his presence known by foiling a plot by Fleming’s chief henchman, a burly fella with scaly skin named… Scales. How appropriate. (He’s played by Vinnie Jones, who could do so much better than this if he wanted.) The second episode pits Vince against a French contract killer who’s been hired to poison the Secretary of Prisons (Richard Schiff) so that Fleming can take over the city’s prison system. This leads to the discovery of a secret society of criminals called Tarot, which will no doubt prove to be a thorn in The Cape’s side.

The Cape is assisted in his efforts by a “sexy crime-fighting blogger” (the official description) named Orwell, played by Summer Glau. She’s given next to nothing to do except poke her nose in at inopportune moments and act as the show’s all-purpose computer hacker. In one especially ridiculous scene, Vince calls her in a moment of desperation and asks her to jam all the cell phones in the area. If this series had been written by Joss Whedon, I’d expect her response to be: “Jam cell phones? I write a blog, you jackass!” Alas, there is no evidence of such wit here.

‘Pilot’ was directed by Simon West, the man behind ‘Lara Croft: Tomb Raider‘ and the upcoming remake of ‘The Mechanic’. The episode is loud, flashy and stupid. It’s also hilariously overburdened by flashbacks, often to things that we’ve just seen. In the worst of these, we’re introduced to Fleming, whose secret identity as Chess is painfully obvious from the first frame we see him. In the very next scene, Vince is captured by Chess, who pulls off his mask to reveal that he’s really Peter Fleming. Just to hammer home the point that this is the same guy, the revelation is accompanied by a flashback to two minutes earlier! It’s absurd!

You know how silly it is that Clark Kent puts on a pair of glasses and suddenly no one recognizes him as Superman? Or how The Lone Ranger wears a simple mask over his eyes to protect his identity? What’s The Cape’s disguise? A hoodie! Yes, he pulls up a hoodie and absolutely no one can recognize him, not even his own son!

Oh my god, where did that guy go? I was looking right at him, but now all I see is this completely different person wearing a hoodie. The first guy, no hoodie. This guy, hoodie. Clearly can’t be the same person. It boggles the mind!

This show is dumb as dirt, utterly tedious, and painfully cheesy without any sense of humor about itself. ‘The Cape’ is suitable only for mocking. Mrs. Z and I did a lot of mocking. We won’t be watching again.


  1. HuskerGuy

    I wanted to like this, but just couldn’t. We watched the first hour seperately and tried to watch the second hour another time but ended up turning it off early.

    I loved the fact they apparently made zero attempts to locate a body or realize there was a grate under the train car that blew up and supposedly killed him. Also, that key card he gave the crooks at the beginning to rob banks was beyond stupid. It also would’ve been traceable back to him.

    Anway, we’ve already given up on it. Hopefully Glau turns up somewhere better next time. Viva la Firefly crew 🙂

    • Josh Zyber

      Not only would the keycard have been traceable back to him, it would have been disabled the moment he was declared a fugitive. (Minority Report has a similar plot hole.)

      I was also perplexed by pretty much everything to do with the Carnival of Crime. Were they bad guy bankrobbers or good guy crimefighters? The show couldn’t seem to decide. By about 45 minutes into the first episode, it was already glossing over the “Crime” portion of their act. By the second episode, there was no mention of it at all.

      It was a pretty inauspicious debut for Vince to start his career as a superhero by robbing a bank. I guess we’re not supposed to think about details like that. Clearly, the show’s creators didn’t.

  2. Patrick A Crone

    NBC had such a great show in HEROES. I wish they could’ve kept the first season’s momentum. The Cape almost seems like a reminder of what went wrong with HEROES. It poorly borrows from Smallville and South Park. That’s right, South Park. The First time I saw an ad for The Cape all I could think of was Mysterion AKA Kenny from the Coon episodes. All he needs is the question mark above his cowl. The Cape is just plain Cheesy and bad. I don’t see it lasting out it’s mid season

  3. Bryan

    I am the absolute target audience for this show – comic book geek, sci-fi fan, I even stayed with “Heroes” through all 4 seasons. But even I couldn’t make it past the pilot episode. I turned it off when the 2nd one started and can’t imagine I’ll watch again.

  4. Keith

    Glad I didn’t waste any of my time. Sounds even worse than I could have imagined! Hopefully they cancel it sooner rather than later so they put The Event back on before people forget about it and the ratings get even worse.

  5. Dont know, had a good time with it, found the first two episodes just cheesy fun, it was definitely stupid in many aspects, key card definitely bugged me, but hey whatever, I’ll watch it till its gone which probably wont be too long 😉

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *