Posted Mon Dec 29, 2008 at 12:00 PM PST by Mike Attebery
Ken Brown wraps up his year end review by handing out awards for the most impressive Blu-ray releases, category by category...
Whether you were burned by HD DVD's overnight disappearance or excited by the end of the so-called format war, you have to admit 2008 has been a great year for high-def enthusiasts of all stripes! Yes, a respectable format bit the dust and yes, many consumers were initially left out in the cold, but the declaration of a definitive winner paved the way for hundreds of new titles, dozens of innovations and creative exclusives, and a much-needed price drop for both releases and hardware. So as you begin plotting your post-Christmas purchases and giftcard cash-ins, you may be wondering... what titles are worth my hard-earned cash?
We already honored the Top Ten releases of the year, but we thought it would be fun to dig in and look at which titles sported the best video, audio, supplements, and more. So read on as we present The Most Impressive Titles of 2008...
|THE MOST IMPRESSIVE TITLES OF 2008
BEST TRANSFER -- NEW RELEASE
In an extremely tight race with some serious contenders, 'The Incredible Hulk' squeezed past every other new release with a gorgeous, jaw-dropping transfer. While its CG-laden visuals aren't quite as stirring as 'No Country For Old Men's gritty and realistic cinematography, Ed Norton and company stormed past the competition with a perfect, reference quality transfer.
Runner Up: No Country for Old Men
BEST TRANSFER -- RECENT RELEASE (Three years or older)
Arguably the finest transfer of the year, 'I, Robot' looks absolutely fantastic in high definition. Vibrant colors, a crystal clear image, and razor sharp detailing made this March release an early 2008 juggernaut that other more criticially-acclaimed titles simply couldn't dethrone. Sure, the movie itself isn't for everyone, but a flawless picture goes a long way.
Runner Up: The Ultimate Matrix Collection
BEST TRANSFER -- CATALOG TITLE (Ten years or older)
You may not think a black and white classic from the '40s could outclass impressive releases like 'The Sand Pebbles,' 'Dr. No,' and 'Baraka,' but you'd be dead wrong. 'Casablanca's Blu-ray debut boasted a stunning transfer that looks as if it were minted yesterday. Detail is revealing, contrast is spot on, and the print appears to be in immaculate shape. Simply beautiful.
Runner Up: The Sand Pebbles
BEST TRANSFER -- ANIMATED
In another close contest, 'Kung Fu Panda' managed to steal top honors from some very deserving competition. Its bristling fur, lush primaries, inviting contrast, and faultless blacks look exceptional, and never exhibit a hint of artifacting, noise, or banding (an animated transfer's primary pitfall). Granted, category leaders like 'Wall•E' come really close, but it's Po that takes the prize.
Runner Up: Wall•E
In what boils down to at least a ten-way toss-up, 'Wanted' emerges unscathed with a precise, powerful, and inarguably perfect DTS HD Master Audio 5.1 surround track that hits hard and never lets up. Its booming LFE support, tenacious rear speaker involvement, and effortless soundfield will yank you in and never let go. In a word, its outstanding.
Runner Up: Transformers
BEST CATALOG AUDIO (Ten years or older)
Using newly-discovered 35mm 3-track recordings, Disney gave one of their most beloved classics a thrilling overhaul. Not only did the studio remix and reinvigorate 'Sleeping Beauty's audio, they did it with style. Better still, the resulting 24-bit DTS HD Master Audio 7.1 monster mix doesn't sound like an unnatural, over-processed gimmick. Bravo Disney, bravo.
Runner Up: Baraka
BEST ANIMATED TITLE
'Kung Fu Panda's video transfer may have stood a hair higher, but when you factor in 'Wall•E's almost equally impressive transfer with its astounding audio, extensive supplemental package, and exclusive features, the little robot that could nudges his way to becoming this year's animated winner. Heartwarming, gorgeous, resonant, and intriguing, it's a true, must-have disc.Runner Up: The Nightmare Before Christmas
Honorable Mention: Bee Movie, Beowulf, Freedom Box Set, Horton Hears a Who, Justice League: The New Frontier, Kung Fu Panda, Persepolis, Shrek the Third, Sleeping Beauty, and Tinker Bell
BEST DOCUMENTARY FEATURE/SERIES
I simply cannnot recommend 'Baraka' enough. Its haunting visuals will stick with you for a long time to come, its chilling soundtrack enhances and inhabits its breathtaking imagery, and its technical presentation is worth legitimate praise. Ironically, many will overlook this title in the holiday hustle and bustle. Stop putting it off and check out this classic documentary today.
Runner Up: When We Left Earth: The NASA Missions
BEST CONCERT/LIVE PERFORMANCE RELEASE
Celine Dion may be devolving into a bizarre parody of herself, but there's no denying the fact that the Blu-ray edition of 'A New Day' is an exceptional release. A show-stopping video transfer, a reference quality audio package (with excellent TrueHD 5.1 and PCM 2.0 tracks), and nearly four hours of documentaries make this one the best of the best. If you're a fan, you can't go wrong.
Runner Up: The Police: Certifiable
BEST TELEVISION RELEASE
I went back and forth between 'Band of Brothers' and 'Lost: The Complete Fourth Season' for a long time, but eventually decided to give my favorite cryptic survivors the edge. Rebounding from a season-hemming writer's strike, boldly changing the rules of their own game, delivering top notch video and audio, and giving me countless supplements to dig through? 'Lost' it is.
Runner Up: Band of Brothers
BEST BOX SET
If you ever decide to drop enough cash to nab the 'Planet of the Apes: 40-Year Evolution Collection,' you won't be disappointed. Every glossy page of its 200-page hardcover insert, every nook of the study box, and every corner of this unexpectedly attractive box set screams "I'm worth every penny." I just wish I had the shelf space to display this one properly.
Runner Up: The Godfather Collection
MOST OVERLOOKED GEM
In case you haven't noticed, my adoration of 'The Sand Pebbles,' a catalog film I discovered for the first time when I reviewed it this year, hasn't waned. The film itself is surprisingly relevant and engaging, its faithful 1080p catalog transfer is second only to 'Casablanca,' its audio is refreshingly good, and its supplemental package is vast. Do yourself a favor and check this one out.
Runner Up: The Proposition
BEST SUPPLEMENTAL PACKAGE
If you haven't dug through 'Sleeping Beauty's supplemental package, you're really missing out. You'll find a Cine-Explore Picture-in-Picture track, an audio commentary, a 45-minute documentary, interactive CG tours, a series of featurettes, deleted scenes, a short film, galleries, storyboards, a trivia track, interactive games, and BD-Live functionality. Whew.
Runner Up: Casablanca
BEST BLU-RAY EXCLUSIVES
HBO went all out with the Blu-ray edition of 'Band of Brothers.' Each episode features an Interactive Field Guide (with accessible bios, videos, factoids, and maps), Picture-in-Picture video commentary from actual Easy Company veterans, and other exclusive goodies that enhance the already impressive standard supplemental package. It'll keep you hooked for days.
Runner Up: Sleeping Beauty
BEST HIGH-DEF STUDIO
You have to hand it to Disney - the studio knows what Blu-ray fans want, understands what the format is capable of, and continually delivers discs that look great, sound wonderful, and are packed to the brim with special features and exclusives. Even mishaps like 'Gangs of New York' can't take away from a slew of high-quality releases including 'The Chronicles of Narnia,' 'Enchanted,' 'Kill Bill,' 'Lost,' 'No Country for Old Men,' 'The Nightmare Before Christmas,' 'Sleeping Beauty,' 'Wall•E,' and more. There was some really stiff competition this year, but no studio made more strides toward greatness than Disney. Kudos.
Runner Up: Universal
And those, my friends, are our picks for the best of the best this year. Have a great holiday season and spend those gift cards wisely!
The latest news on all things 4K Ultra HD, blu-ray and Gear.